Welcome to KIWIreviews - product reviews
•  click here to return to the homepage  •
Welcome visitor.Join us or log in

Product reviews on KIWIreviews.co.nz : Sunday 22nd September 2019 - 07:29:49

QuickSearch for:    What is QuickSearch?
QuickJump to:    What is QuickJump?
logon name: p/w:  
I want to:

You Are Here...

Home > Categories > Books > Kids - General > Thornhill review

« How Not To Stop A Kidnap Plot reviewHow Not To Stop A Kidnap PlotRory the Dinosaur Needs a Christmas Tree reviewRory the Dinosaur Needs a Christmas Tree »

Score: 9.1/10  [2 reviews]
4 out of 5
ProdID: 7748 - Thornhill
Author: Pam Smy

Sample/s Supplied by:
Click to search for all products supplied by Scholastic (NZ)

Disclosure StatementFULL DISCLOSURE: A number of units of this product have, at some time, been supplied to KIWIreviews by the company for the purposes of unbiased, independent reviews. No fee was accepted by KIWIreviews or the reviewers themselves - these are genuine, unpaid consumer reviews.
October 2017

Thornhill product reviews

As she unpacks in her new bedroom, Ella is irresistibly drawn to the big old house that she can see out of her window. Surrounded by overgrown gardens, barbed wire fences, and "keep out" signs, it looks derelict.

But that night, a light goes on in one of the windows. And the next day she sees a girl in the grounds. Ella is hooked. The house has a story to tell. She is sure of it.

Enter Thornhill, Institute for Children, and discover the dark secrets that lie within. But once inside, will you ever leave?

Forget what you think a novel should be and what it should look like. Thornhill is a story in two strands, one in pictures and one in words - working together as a whole. An extraordinary, unsettling and gripping tale for readers aged 10 and over.

Check out Scholastic (NZ) onlineClick here to see all the listings for Scholastic (NZ) Visit their website They do not have a Twitter account Check them out on Facebook They do not have a YouTube Channel They do not have a Pinterest board They do not have an Instagram channel

david fickling books   kids book   pam smy   parallel story   prose story   scholastic   spooky   story in graphics   thornhill
Other listings you may be interested in:
The Invincible Iron Man: An Origin StoryThe Invincible Iron Man: An Origin Story
Rating: 9.8
Geronimo's Christmas CollectionGeronimo's Christmas Collection
Rating: 9.1
Singing For FreedomSinging For Freedom
Rating: 10.0
The Wonky Donkey - Platinum EditionThe Wonky Donkey - Platinum Edition
Rating: 10.0
The Desert RailwayThe Desert Railway
Rating: 7.5
Scream #1: The Human FlytrapScream #1: The Human Flytrap
Rating: 9.8
How I love You, DaddyHow I love You, Daddy
Rating: 9.4
And Did Those Feet...And Did Those Feet...
Rating: 8.3
My Perfect PupMy Perfect Pup
Rating: 8.8
Thelma the UnicornThelma the Unicorn
Rating: 10.0
Cavemice #8: Surfing for SecretsCavemice #8: Surfing for Secrets
Rating: 10.0
Uncover : The Human BodyUncover : The Human Body
Rating: 10.0
Conspiracy 365 : 2 : FebruaryConspiracy 365 : 2 : February
Rating: 9.0

Product reviews...

Everyone is welcome to post a review. You will need to Join up or log in to post yours.

Click here to read the profile of kiwiblondie

Review by: kiwiblondie (Michelle)
Dated: 25th of November, 2017

Link to this review Report this review


This Review: 8.8/10
Score 8 out of 10
Value for Money:
Score 8 out of 10
Score 10 out of 10
Personal Choice:
Score 9 out of 10

I have read a few books in the past that tell two tales in one book and usually really enjoy it but find it takes a while to sort the different times in my head but with the way this book is done it was really easy to read. At first I thought it was a diary with pictures for illustration purposes but soon realised the pictures told their own story. I could clearly tell what was happening at any given time and it was easy to follow the story of Mary although no details were given I found that I was sympathetic to how she was treated by the unnamed bully and I spent most the story hoping that she got away and had a "happy ever after" but it was made clear that she never had the chance but no details were given so a big question is what happened to her and how did it happen?

I get my love of books and reading from my mum and I came home from work one day to find she had started reading the book but she said she found it hard to follow the story as she hadn't realised the pictures were a story on their own.

I will definitely read this book again as it was easy for me to finish in a few hours even with kids busy around me and needing my attention and would gladly let my sons read it as I think it is something that parents should always be teaching kids, not to be nasty and how to handle situations that can be uncomfortable, you don't have to keep quiet when someone is being mean to you and sometimes it is easier if they feel they are discussing a book/story.

Click here to read the profile of savta

Review by: savta (Jo)
Dated: 12th of October, 2017

Link to this review Report this review


This Review: 9.5/10
Score 9 out of 10
Value for Money:
Score 10 out of 10
Score 10 out of 10
Personal Choice:
Score 9 out of 10

The price and the weight of this volume are quite hefty, but there again it packs a lot of pages into one story and is a book I will read many times so it is important that the binding will stand up to lots of handling. The reason I will read it again is due to the quality of the images - black and white, and amazingly detailed. If pictures could talk ... but then again, they do!

Neither a graphic novel nor a prose work, this story combines the two in separate narratives that become closer as the story progresses. This is the first time I have encountered a novel with this sort of layout, but I found it very easy to follow. I read a similar book recently where the two strands were separated by the fonts used - one strand was written in roman script and the other in italic. That was actually harder to read because my eyes kept adjusting to the script. In Thornhill, the divisions could not be more obvious.

The theme of the book is that of isolation and its long term effect on a young person. Neither Mary nor Ella is alone by choice; circumstances have forced them into providing their own entertainment by pursuing an activity they enjoy. For Mary, it is crafting dolls; for Ella, it is exploring her surroundings and uncovering the mysteries they conceal. The adults in both of their lives have something to answer for as they fail in their duty to provide for their children and ensure they are happy and safe.

This is essentially a ghost story and one which over tens will enjoy if they are into this genre. It is not too scary; although the subtext is quite dark, there are no gory details included to upset a young reader. The cruelty shown by Mary's companions towards her it something any child who is familiar with bullying will recognise. The emotion generated will be sympathy for Mary rather than fear at her situation, although some readers may wonder why the grown-ups in her life were not more proactive in dealing with the bullies.

I found the ending of the book predictable, but I was left with one unanswered question - what happened to Mary? There are hints all the way through the story, but no firm indication as to the precise outcome. I think one more graphic chapter combining the stories and including a definitive explanation to wind up the mystery would have rounded it off more successfully. I still had questions after two readings, and I am no wiser. However, it is a beautifully produced work and one which as an adult I enjoyed every bit as much as a younger person would.

Guest comments...

Random listing from 'Books'...

Score: 9.0
Product reviews for listing 1637: Ordinary Heroes
Written by Scott Turow

Product image for Ordinary Heroes"All parents keep secrets from their children. My father, it seemed, kept more than most..."

Whilst mourning the death of his father, courtroom journalist Stewart Dublin decides to research the life of a man he always respected, always admired, but possibly never quite knew...

As a young, idealistic lawyer during the last terrible months of the Second World War, David Dublin is sent to the European Front - ostensibly to ... more...

Go to the listing

General Disclaimer...

Protected by Copyscape Plagiarism Checker - Do not copy content from this page. Creative Commons Licence All trademarks, images and copyrights on this site are owned by their respective companies.
KIWIreviews is an independent entity, part of the ePLURIBUS.nz Network. This is a free public forum presenting user opinions on selected products, and as such the views expressed do not necessarily reflect the opinion of KIWIreviews.co.nz and are protected under New Zealand law by the "Honest Opinion" clause of the Defamation Act of 1992. KIWIreviews accepts no liability for statements made on this site, under the assumption that they are the true and honest opinions of the individual posters. In most cases, prices and dates stated are approximate and should be considered as only guidelines.

"Character - the willingness to accept responsibility for one's own life - is the source from which self respect springs."
Joan Didion (1934 - ), 'Slouching Towards Bethlehem'

KIWIreviews Help GuideClick here for the Help Guide Subscribe to our Twitter streamVisit our
Twitter feed
Visit our Facebook pageVisit our
Facebook page
Visit our YouTube ChannelVisit our
YouTube channel
Follow us on instagramVisit our
Instagram album
Visit our Google+ pageVisit our
Google+ page
Visit our Flickr photostreamVisit our
Flickr photostream